Wednesday, November 15, 2006

REIT Delete

Equity Residential (EQR) $51.77

Fellow Investor
, the strangest stocks in the US market are REITs. Property companies traditionally traded at a discount to book but, with a wave of the tax wand, they have outperformed the market greatly in the past seven years. This is going to be somebody's big mistake. Don't let it be yours.

I am using EQR as an example only. A quick look at other REITs suggests a similar story. EQR is big and widely held. Fidelity, for example, owns 7.8% and Vanguard 5.7% so its probably well represented in a portfolio near you.

The first suprise is the yield - it is, against expectations, only 3.5%. Even grossed up for tax that is not automatically compelling. But the real problem needs some deep digging. Let's have a look at the latest 10-K, for the year to December 2005.

EQR owns 926 residential properties in 31 states and D.C., all valued at $13.7 billion. It finances these assets with $8.1 billion of debt/prefs and $4.9 billion in equity. In 2005 EBIT was $512m compared to c.$370m in interest and pref coupons. In other words, ignoring the whole slew of one-offs and after deducting further for minority interests, net income available for the common was only about $70m; peanuts - a return of less than 2% on book. The dividend was $496m, way higher. How come?

Defenders of REITs make two points, one good, one bad. The good one is that net income doesn't capture all of the gain, there is capital appreciation, too. The bad is the notorious FFO, funds from operations. This is a special measure for REITs that adds back depreciation to income. Like all of these non-GAAP treatments it should be viewed sceptically. Depreciation is a real expense, or a real estimate of future expense. In this case it is a provision for future works necessary to maintain the buildings and fixtures on the estate. If there is over depreciation then they should change their depreciation policy.

Happily, there is a way to measure the true value created that takes on board both these arguments and gives an idea of what the sustainable dividend might be. From year end 2002 to 2005, common shareholders' equity grew from $14.3 to $15.7 per share. In addition, the common received $5.2 in dividends. This equates to a compound growth per year of 13.4%, the equivalent of being able to pay $655m on last year's book.

So the good news is that the common dividend is covered, but barely. The bad news is twofold. If capital growth slows or, as seems more likely, reverses, the dividend would be uncovered. More fundamentally, this $655m or so is the total increase in value. There is nothing else to play with, no FFO, no other magic pockets. To value EQR you must focus only on that amount and its effect on the book value of $4.9 billion.

So we come to the crunch. What would you pay for that book and that ability to grow (or not)? The tax benefit is nice but it doesn't make the 3.5% dividend grow any faster. The surprising answer, for the current market at any rate, is $15 billion or over three times book. That is absurd. The capital growth providing most of the dividend/valuation support is far less secure than a third subordinated bond from a highly leveraged buy out. A 13.4% yield for such a bond might give you par or slightly over. But would you pay three times par?

Common shareholders are conniving to keep the stock price up - against themselves.

Here is a handy table showing the largest constituents of each other REIT subsector and their price-to-book values:

REIT Sector Name Ticker Price-to-Book

Diversified Vornado Realty VNO 3.65
Healthcare Health Care Property HCP 3.93
Hotel Host Hotels HST 2.43
Industrial ProLogis PLD 2.72
Office Equity Office EOP 2.51
Retail Simon Property SPG 6.96

5 comments:

OTM Radio Schedule said...

this is good work. Who wrote this? I am an investment advisor and would like to talk to the author.

Thanks

Steve Pomeranz
stevep@slpomeranz.com

StockReply said...

Thanks, Steve, appreciated. We are writing to you.

John Sturges said...

Too bad I cannot include my chart of the North Am. REIT Index history in semi-log. It would be obvious that have been pushing the envelope on valuations since early 2004 on a historical basis. This equity index which has a long history of 8.8% yield is now down to 4.39% and the last time I looked they haven't changed the tax law or regulations on REITs. Good comments by stockreply. Sam Zell is right to sell EOP. Hedge funds are looking not for RIET economic value but for the additional leverage they can gain by having access to non-recourse lending for hedge fund activities. Sears Holdings is no longer real estate but now a thinly disguised HF.

Anonymous said...

see our blog -

[url=http://trailfire.com/amoxicillin] amoxicillin rash [/url]

http://trailfire.com/amoxicillin
[url=http://trailfire.com/amoxicillin] amoxicillin shelf life [/url]

Anonymous said...

[p]Clarke, who replaced Mark [url=http://www.fashionhermesbagsuk.co.uk]discount hermes bags kelly[/url] Anson in the post . getting a considerable element in leather-based productions, birkin replica are well-known using the exceptional and stylish taste . One of this [url=http://www.springhermeshandbags.co.uk]Hermes handbags UK [/url] company from Hermes is with Birkin handbag another quality product hand woven . Lv Handbags Outlet There we had been really glad for you to spray this incredible Randy Fenoli with Say Yes to clothing fame for own [url=http://www.fashionhermesbagsuk.co.uk]hermes bags kelly[/url] future screen print variant . Beckham, that may not completely do without having the ornament involving wine red regular sewing bag, plus the tote also continue the style of middle skirt [url=http://www.springhermeshandbags.co.uk]hermes handbags kelly[/url] of tall stomach . All of us who has ever previously reached a telephone call in a odd selection realizes just how shocking it can be when you are getting a good [url=http://www.fashionhermesbagsuk.co.uk]hermes bags birkin on sale[/url] hang up call up . Its golden lock isn't able to only protect itself, but catches me . Hermes is a prominent brand in clothing and luxurious accessories.[/p][p]These kind of Hermes bags tend to be outfitted using glowing man highlights and also signature hardware from Hermes Purses Wall socket shop . zaklyuchenie, Hermes bag, in all its glory, and continues to fascinate and even dreams will warm up and a strong desire . But do not [url=http://www.springhermeshandbags.co.uk]cheap hermes handbags birkin[/url] despair . However, [url=http://www.fashionhermesbagsuk.co.uk]hermes bags[/url] now the replica So Black Bags have been available in the market and actually have become one of the hottest items . It is also made of different materials . They have big types if you actually should pack many different concerns for an overnighter, or tiny dainty types just big adequate to hold your necessities . Merely seize the opportunity end up being the focus regarding picture ahead of time!

To manage anyone favorable totes nicely, the first step would be to adjust clinical cleaning methods.[/p]